First, slow down. Multiple offers are leverage, and leverage wasted in excitement does not come back. Every offer gets read past its headline number: financing type and lender strength, deposit size, contingencies, appraisal risk, closing timeline, and any terms that touch your next move.
The highest price is not automatically the strongest offer. A financed offer above asking can die at appraisal. A clean cash offer slightly below it closes. The comparison that matters is expected net proceeds weighted by probability of actually closing, and an experienced agent prices that risk for you.
Process matters too. A deadline for highest and best, communicated to all parties, keeps the competition honest and often improves every offer on the table. Rangely runs this process for sellers with the discipline it deserves, and documents it so the decision holds up in hindsight.